Optical data transmission
Light - an alternative to radio?
When it comes to wireless transmission methods in the industrial environment, we usually talk about radio. To what extent could the medium of light also be an alternative to cable?
High data rates, robustness, low energy consumption, data security, electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) and network capability: the requirements for exchanging data are enormous in the field of manufacturing and process automation, where industrial systems are becoming increasingly complex and more and more sensors, machines and control and regulation units are communicating with each other. With these requirements, the demand for a replacement for today's predominant wired fieldbus systems is growing. This is because wireless systems promise greater reliability and safety than wear-prone and expensive special cables or slip rings, particularly in the case of moving or moving system parts such as gripper arms or lifting equipment. They also enable faster installation and offer greater flexibility. Last but not least, they are always required when laying a signal cable from the sensors or actuators to the control unit is completely impossible or very time-consuming, thus achieving significant cost savings in assembly and maintenance.
The state of the art
The state of the art in industrial systems today is wired transmission protocols ranging from a few kbit/s to 12.5 Gbit/s. Representative examples are Ethernet 10/100/1000Base-T, Ethercat, Profibus or Profinet. Higher data rates are achieved, for example, with 10GBaseT or PCIe with copper cables or 100GbE via fiber optics. In comparison, there are various radio-based technologies which, however, must be critically scrutinized in terms of net data rate and reliability. These include, for example, IEEE 802.11n or 802.11ac with theoretical gross data rates of 600 Mbit/s and 1300 Mbit/s respectively. If a network of this type is operated in a certain area with obstacles, EMC interference and several subscribers, the net data rate may be reduced due to the temporary interference of the transmission channel. Real-time communication is almost impossible with these wireless technologies and is always associated with limitations.
In contrast to radio solutions, optical wireless communication - also known as Li-Fi technology - works with a physically limited bandwidth in the THz range. Unlike radio-based communication, there is no government regulation of the spectrum worldwide. A practical limitation of the data rate is given by available optoelectronic components, which are used for modulation and demodulation. Unlike radio technologies, wireless communication based on light is much less sensitive to interference. In addition to the high net data rates of up to 12.5 Gbit/s, Li-Fi systems ensure stable operation in EMC-affected areas. They can operate at different wavelengths - mainly in the visible and near infrared range.
There are currently Li-Fi systems with various proprietary approaches. In addition, various organizations are working on standardization. The IEEE standard 802.15.7, for example, offers data rates from a few kbit/s up to 100 Mbit/s. Higher data rates are currently under discussion. The Infrared Data Association (IrDA) has published well-known standards (SIR, MIR, FIR, VFIR) with up to 16 Mbit/s as well as newer versions (Giga-IR) with up to 1 Gbit/s. Versions for data rates of 5 and 10 Gbit/s are currently being worked on.
Line of sight - disadvantage and advantage at the same time
The biggest disadvantage and advantage of Li-Fi technology is the need for a line of sight. Multi-path propagation, as is known from infrared remote control and can be used for simple handling, is theoretically conceivable with higher data rates. However, with the technologies available today, this is not feasible in a competitive market environment. This is why Li-Fi focuses primarily on point-to-point and point-to-multipoint solutions. In this respect, cables, connectors and radio links with line of sight can be replaced by Li-Fi solutions with high data rates, real-time capability and interference immunity. In contrast, classic wireless networks offer the greatest possible mobility at comparatively low data rates, whereas real-time capability is usually not an issue.
How Li-Fi works
In general, a Li-Fi HotSpot data link consists of a permanently installed optical transmitter/receiver module that represents an access point for a defined spatial application area. A second optical module can be placed in this area and establish a data connection. The distance between the two modules and the spot size of the emitted light are important for Li-Fi HotSpots. In a first approximation, the spot size changes linearly with the distance. The distance can be increased until the minimum sensitivity of the receiver is reached. Alternatively, the beam angle can be reduced to further increase the distance. A major advantage of Li-Fi is that several data links can be set up in parallel using the room multiplex method without interference between the individual connections. And each connection can operate at the maximum available data rate. There is also the option of using time-division multiplexing to establish point-to-multipoint connections.
In addition to stationary installation, applications in which two Li-Fi modules move in relation to each other on a rail system are also conceivable. If, for example, a moving camera is installed for process control, the video data can be transmitted wirelessly in real time during movement. A solution with cables would have disadvantages in terms of robustness and durability. Although special cable chains could compensate for this disadvantage, the speed of the moving modules would then be limited.
Figure 1 shows a Li-Fi module that optically bridges a Gigabit Ethernet 1000Base-T connection. Users can integrate such a device into their existing infrastructure via CAT5 cable without any additional effort. The device contains a special data bridge that converts the Ethernet protocol into an optical wireless protocol. The special conversion enables point-to-point connections to be established with this module, which transmit data in real time. The optical connection can operate in half or full duplex mode. In the latter case, data is transmitted and received simultaneously on the optical wireless link.
The Li-Fi module shown has a size of 10 cm × 10 cm × 6 cm and is powered by a 5 V plug-in power supply unit. The optical transmitter consists of an infrared laser source. This is operated in such a way that eye safety (laser class 1) is guaranteed. Depending on the application, the size of the prototype shown can be optimized and made much smaller. Integration into systems with different structural requirements would be possible. Depending on the spot size, the range can be more than ten meters.
Figure 2 shows the measurement of the net data rate of an optical wireless data connection with Gigabit Ethernet interface. The average net data rate is around 900 MBit/s. This corresponds to a utilization of the Gigabit Ethernet channel of 90 %. The measurement was carried out using the iPerf tool (with jPerf GUI extension) and two standard PCs with a Windows 7 operating system and Gigabit Ethernet port. One PC acted as a client, the other as a server.
Finally, Figure 3 shows the net data rate and the bit error rate (BER) over the beam angle. The bit error rate is constantly below 10-11 over the entire range and is therefore virtually error-free. The optical setup of this solution is chosen so that the optical power is relatively evenly distributed within the spot. The power drops sharply at the boundaries.
Possible applications for Li-Fi modules in industry can be found in classic point-to-point and point-to-multipoint connections for real-time control of milling machines, robots or rotating systems, for example. Li-Fi modules can also supplement or replace established methods of communication between fixed stations and passing trolleys on production lines. Moving camera systems can also be equipped with this technology to transmit video data to a base station for process control, for example. Current Li-Fi modules have the status of demonstrators or prototypes and can be transferred to products at competitive costs in the near future, depending on application-specific requirements.
Authors:
Dr. Frank Deicke is Group Leader Optical Sensors & Communication at Fraunhofer IPMS,
Michael Faulwaßer works in the Optical Wireless Communication department at Fraunhofer IPMS.













